If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ You must be an NCRS member before you can post: click the Join NCRS link above to join. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. If you have trouble logging in you can clear your cookies here!
Off Topic But Corvette Related - China Ball Joints - Beware
Re: Off Topic But Corvette Related - China Ball Joints - Beware
Originally posted by Joe Lucia (12484)
Rich------
Was this an OEM ball joint or was this an aftermarket replacement? If the latter, it's probably of the same ilk as the set you pictured above.
I'd be surprised if this was an OEM ball joint. Some OEM ball joints are very likely made in China but not made like this ball joint.
Joe, Sorry I just noticed your 2nd question......
Yes the ball joints in the first post were aftermarket. I don't have any other details of the parts at this time. I can get more info if you're curious.
Where it broke almost appears as if it was a spin welded piece, but also shows signs of a serious internal casting defect. Regardless, a bad part. Also, I was at a friend's repair business the other day and I explained this failure and described where it broke. he said he has had similar experiences with other marques. In one case a well know high end Japanese manufacturer car brand. I won't downplay it, but it began with a "L".
He said the car had under 100k miles and had a identical ball joint failure. Tore up the car wheel well area considerably.
Re: Off Topic But Corvette Related - China Ball Joints - Beware
Originally posted by Richard Mozzetta (13499)
Joe, Sorry I just noticed your 2nd question......
Yes the ball joints in the first post were aftermarket. I don't have any other details of the parts at this time. I can get more info if you're curious.
Where it broke almost appears as if it was a spin welded piece, but also shows signs of a serious internal casting defect. Regardless, a bad part. Also, I was at a friend's repair business the other day and I explained this failure and described where it broke. he said he has had similar experiences with other marques. In one case a well know high end Japanese manufacturer car brand. I won't downplay it, but it began with a "L".
He said the car had under 100k miles and had a identical ball joint failure. Tore up the car wheel well area considerably.
Rich
Rich------
The ball studs should be forged steel. If these were some sort of casting, that's a major problem right there.
Re: Off Topic But Corvette Related - China Ball Joints - Beware
Joe, I chose the wrong words when I said "casting defect". I have no knowledge of it's manufacturing process, but just by observation it reminds me of a defective 5" bench vice I bought from Wilton USA several years ago.
It broke at it's outer lower jaw base and the company rep wanted detail photos to cover it under warranty. They refused at first. it was about a week in my possession.
When I sent the macro photos showing the internal flaws, the rep then conceded and said it was a serious manufacturing defect. I have the photos in a old email stashed away somewhere. They sent me a brand new vice, still in use today.
So I have a 50% hit rate with recent vice purchases.
BTW, The Wilton company manufactures here in the US and overseas. My vice came from China.
Comment